With Claire Scodellaro, sociologist and demographer, Alain Perroud, psychiatrist and psychotherapist, and Manon Vinerier reading the diaries. Illustration: Angèle (Advitam agency).
Prologue
The first time I saw Mathilde, she seemed so lively and good-natured I immediately wanted to get to know her better. Mathilde is a pretty brunette who smokes like a chimney and loves to quote lines from Little Miss Sunshine. We met in 2015, at a performing arts centre where we were both employed as ushers. The job was a pleasant one and gave us enough time to befriend each other. Soon enough, we were getting along and made it a habit to go out for a drink after work. I would order French fries; she would drink red wine; and that’s how we became good friends. One day, in the middle of a conversation, she told me that ever since she nearly died, she has put a lot of things in perspective. Seeing the surprise on my face, she breathed one word: anorexia.
Read more
Anorexia? What —?
At the time, I didn’t know much about the illness. In that moment, the word only brings to my mind the emaciated bodies of models the press talked about in the 2000’s. It also reminds me of those teenage girls who starve themselves with a determination that seems both deadly and unfathomable.
The thing is, I just can’t connect the dots between those facts, those images, and my friend. Something doesn’t add up.
Later on, as we grew closer, she began to open up about her illness and even showed me pictures of her that her mother took when she was still deep in anorexia. “It doesn’t even look like me,” Mathilde says, “I look like a zombie.” In the pictures, she appears severely underweight. But what I find most disturbing is the look on her face — identical in every picture. “Looking at me, you’d think the only emotion I could feel was sorrow,” she says. “That’s what my father told me; he said it was terrible to see my eyes like that, as if I was always internally screaming.” “Even beyond that,” I tell her, “you aren’t smiling in any of the pictures.” “Yeah, no, it wasn’t my thing,” she laughs. “I was always sulky. It’s weird, isn’t it, when you know me as I am now?” It is.
I felt the desire to understand what had happened to Mathilde. How was it possible that such a lively young woman as herself had fallen into the most radical form of restriction? This is the question I hope to answer with this series of podcasts. Following the story of my friend Mathilde, I will conduct an in-depth investigation, in an attempt to figure out what exactly is at stake with anorexia.
A Fancy Girl
To begin my investigation, I go for a coffee at Mathilde’s place. I need her to explain how everything started for her, how she developed anorexia.
Read more
“I began to restrict my food intake when I was 20, the summer of 2010. I was feeling bad about myself, as if my body was not as it should have been. For me, anorexia is an inner turmoil that can’t, or won’t, be expressed outwardly until it becomes physically noticeable.”
Before we go any further, here are a few things you should know about Mathilde.
First, she was born and grew up in Paris in a rather privileged environment. Her mother is a celebrated dancer and her father also works in the entertainment industry as a technician. This is also where Mathilde works now, among the public.
At 20 years old, when she became ill, she was a student of Art History at Sorbonne University and shared a flat with her boyfriend.
Mathilde can trace her feeling of being unwell back to her childhood. “At the age of 9 or 10, I was already feeling a sense of unease in my body. I had always been very thin growing up, and all of a sudden my body changed, I felt less pretty, less interesting, I didn’t like how I looked.” When I ask her how she saw herself at 20, she reports feeling a sort of inadequacy between herself and her body. “I would look at my reflection and feel like that body wasn’t me. I had curves, but I didn’t think my body was ugly; I knew girls who looked like me or had even bigger bodies and they were really pretty. I didn’t think models were better than me. What I wanted was to make it all less visible; to erase those parts of my body and make that heavy sensuality fade away.”
I ask Mathilde to show me pictures of women that her 20-year-old self liked and deemed close to how she felt deep inside. She answers with names of iconic women from the 1960’s, among which Jane Birkin and Françoise Hardy. She immediately points out how thin the latter looked, and how she equated being thin with being able to wear anything you wished, and looking good no matter what. As if any piece of clothing looked at once elegant or fancy on a thin body. She also points out the melancholy, mysterious air of these women she calls “child-women”, whose femininity blurs the boundaries between girlhood and womanhood.
When Mathilde describes her ideal of thinness to me, what she calls “la Parisienne”, I’m surprised to hear her talk about not only desire but love, life, adventure — instead, I expected some cold description reminiscent of models as seen in the glossy paper of magazines. At this point, I feel like there is something else behind her idealized vision of thinness, something deeper than the mere desire to meet beauty standards.
I reach out to Claire Scodellaro, lecturer in sociology and demographic studies at the University of Paris 1 Pantheon-Sorbonne. Part of her work focuses on EDs (Eating Disorders), which include anorexia nervosa. She emphasizes the importance of socio-cultural factors in the development of these illnesses, and explains that, in many cases, the people who develop anorexia nervosa exhibit three particular social features:
- More often than not, they are women. She observed that 3% of 17-year-old girls suffer from an eating disorder, compared to 0,1% in boys.
- Most of the time, they are young people, between the ages of 16 and 22 — which can be explained by the fact that adolescence and early adulthood are times of development, but also of great vulnerability.
- In 60% of cases, they come from a relatively affluent social background, or are in a dynamic of upward social mobility.
Mathilde’s case matches those three characteristics. I wonder then what might account for such socio-cultural inequalities, and why women are the most exposed.
“With anorexia nervosa, the most salient feature is the control around one’s food intake — but in fact, the act of control itself is often sought after. Exposure to violence may be one contributing factor in this pursuit of control. When an individual is confronted with a situation of domination or submission, their stress response might be to seek control over themselves, to engage in restrictive behaviors as a coping mechanism to regain control over their life. Such a response can often be observed when people experience a feeling of inferiority or belittlement. And it so happens that women are more often on the receiving end of interpersonal violence and systemic inferiorization in social relationships. This is one of the factors that can explain why women are more likely to develop eating disorders — in this case, anorexia nervosa.”
To some women, seeking control over their bodies is a way to cope with the oppression that weighs on them in our society. But it is not the only factor that should be taken into account. Claire Scodellaro points out that, in our western societies, thinness is perceived as a sign of belonging to a socially elevated class — which accounts for the correlation between anorexia and affluent social backgrounds.
“The body is seen as a defining feature,” Claire Scodellaro explains, “the central object in the way we identify the social status of individuals. In that respect, thinness is equated with a mark of higher social belonging — especially for women. Looking back in history, it appears that thinness became an ideal for women at the end of the 19th century, primarily among women from the middle to upper class (“the bourgeoisie”). Their goal was to differentiate themselves from women belonging to the lower class, who had stronger, stouter bodies that handled physical labor, all the more so since their access to food was easier as famines receded.”
But let’s get back to Mathilde: “On the one hand, there was my body that wasn’t me; and on the other hand, there was me. To me, the appeal of being thin was to look how I felt deep inside.” At 20 years old, Mathilde saw a link between living in a thin body and living an ambitious life. During our discussion, she underlines a connection between misogynistic social injunctions forced onto women and her own belief that having a sensual body was an obstacle to being deemed “interesting”, to people seeing her for who she was. “I didn’t want people to see a bra size or hips or a cinched waist when they looked at me; I wanted them to see me as a person; not a woman, a person. When I began to pursue thinness, I think what I wanted was a body that would allow me to be myself.” Mathilde also adds that when she began to lose weight, when her breasts became flat, she experienced a sense of relief, feeling more in control of her sensuality than ever before. She says she could choose what to show or not to show, without it being “there”, immediately and de facto visible to the eye, like mere “pieces of meat”.
But I perceive something deeper lying behind this desire for thinness, something that affects all women. Mathilde associates being thin with the possibility of being not only desired but loved. Claire Scodellaro mentioned the violence inflicted on women. The hypersexualization of women’s bodies is one of its manifestations, which explains that femininity might be experienced as a burden. Mathilde emphasizes the part that early puberty played in her feeling of disconnect between her body and herself: her body changed rapidly, but inside she didn’t feel any different. All of the sudden, she became “a kind of sexually attractive thing”, earning unsolicited and unwanted comments or looks that concerned her body and not herself as a person.
Now, I understand what factors might have led Mathilde to desire and pursue thinness; but what I can’t grasp is the turning point when she first associated this desire with food restriction. When I ask my friend about it, she says it certainly did not happen overnight, and recalls a long period of time when she felt uncomfortable in her body, a mental state that culminated one summer when she thought, “I’m not feeling well and I’ve had enough of not feeling well”.
Mathilde suffered from restrictive anorexia, a subtype of anorexia nervosa, which also encompasses a binge eating/purging subtype. She defines restriction as the progressive diminution of the types and amounts of food that one consumes. “The way I started off resembled a classic dieting behaviour: I cut out cakes and desserts. But then after a few weeks, it didn’t feel like enough, so I cut out cheese and dairy. Then I moved on to cutting carbs.” Mathilde is describing the vicious cycle of restriction: once she excluded a food type from her diet, she wouldn’t allow it back on her plate, which meant that the list of what she would allow herself to eat was getting shorter and shorter over time. Were she to break the rules, the result would have been intense anxiety and panic.
As Mathilde reminds me, anorexia nervosa is a mental illness, with a psychological dimension that she sums up as “deluding yourself into thinking — and being convinced — that you can live your life without eating”.
I called Alain Perroud, a psychiatrist specializing in the treatment of eating disorders. “Contrary to popular belief,” he says, “girls from rich families are not the ones who become ill most frequently. Nowadays, they are simply people who live in wealthy countries, where food is abundant, the economic system follows the Western model, with a particular emphasis on image and media, and among these images, a female archetype promoting leanness or thinness as an important aesthetic feature.”
I ask him about the triggering factors in the development of an ED: “One of the most common and yet least known factors is the mere fact of going on a diet.”
Going on a diet. That was how it began for Mathilde, in this pretty mundane but highly praised way. She tells me how, in the beginning, everyone would comment on her weight loss, complimenting her, telling her how pretty she was, etc. But those comments only fueled the disorder: why should she stop when everyone was praising her?
Alain Perroud said that going on a diet could trigger the whole disorder, simply through losing a few pounds or falling into a vicious cycle. “The vicious cycle” — something I don’t quite understand yet. What could turn an apparently virtuous cycle (being mindful of one’s nutrition) into such a dangerous one? So I ask Mathilde this question: Why would one keep restricting their food intake once they had managed to lose weight? “For the sensation you get out of it,” she says. “It becomes similar to drugs, to an addiction; at the beginning you feel all-powerful — I didn’t want it to stop.”
Honeymoon
“I wasn’t feeling good about myself when I became ill, and so feeling a bit of self-confidence, of safety and control over my life, that was something that was really hard to let go of.”
Read more
Mathilde describes how she felt during the first months of her illness. “The vicious aspect of the cycle is the same as with drug use, because when you experience those sensations, you don’t want them to stop, so you keep going, further and further. Like a drug addict who needs to increase the dose in order to really feel it. You feel lighter, you feel good, as if ‘cleaned’, more peaceful. At least in the beginning, I was only experiencing pleasant sensations — which is why this illness is so insidious.”
To talk about the first months of anorexia, Mathilde uses the following expression: “the honeymoon.” “It was like meeting a new friend, toxic though she may be, but it’s the phase when she becomes your closest friend, you know?”
Psychiatrist Alain Perroud explains: “The emotional experience of the illness is very particular. The first phase of the experience is like a honeymoon when things still feel pleasant, and even thrilling: there is a sense of exhilaration that comes with being able to restrict your food intake and lose weight. These positive sensations are fueled by the praise coming from other people, but they also stem from a biological phenomenon: the process through which stored fat is burned. Ketone bodies are released, which produces an exciting effect on the brain. That is one of the reasons why the early stage of the illness is often suffused with pleasant sensations.”
The thrill of restriction is familiar to Mathilde, who simultaneously developed a form of hyperactivity, sleeping less and feeling the need to move more. “I had never had more energy than at this time of my life,” she says, “which does not help you realize that you are ill. Your body is always in motion, even when I was seated I could not remain still. I would walk a lot and stopped using public transport, no matter the weather.”
Alain Perroud explains that this hyperactivity is linked to several phenomena that come with rapid weight loss: “The need to keep moving becomes an obsession. People fear that they might produce more fat if they stay put, and regain weight. Another hypothesis would be that hyperactivity is brought on as an instinctive response because it increases internal body temperature, which counteracts the constant cold experienced by people who are malnourished and underweight. A more phylogenetic hypothesis is that we possess a predisposition to hyperactivity when food is lacking: the brain experiences restriction as famine, which produces the same response that was probably a defense mechanism when food was scarce and humans needed to stay active to try and find food.”
Mathilde proceeds to explain how she would view her food intake through the lens of calories. “When I started to count calories, it wasn’t even about whether it was composed of fat or carbs or anything, it was just about the numbers, and the control I got from it. This is one of the lingering effects of the illness I still experience today. It wasn’t about the food anymore; it was about adding numbers and trying to get the sum to be as small as possible. My meals were carefully measured; I would eat very slowly and drink a lot of diet soda.”
At this point in our discussion, the clock hits noon, we’re getting hungry and we need to go to the supermarket to buy something to eat. Mathilde uses the opportunity to explain how shopping at the supermarket went for her when she was ill. At the time, the process involved a lot of staring at the items, picking up things to read through the nutritional information — especially calories, quantities of fats and sugar — before putting them back on the shelves, sometimes coming back to them to take another look… And the operation could repeat itself on and on for hours. There were even times when she’d spend a full hour in the supermarket and overthink everything so much that she would end up buying nothing at all. She also mentions another lasting consequence of anorexia: “The reason why I only buy soy cream is that my stomach can no longer process cream. That’s what happens when you cut out food groups from your diet.” Ready-made meals were out of the question: “This is why I started to cook everything myself; because with ready-made meals, you have no way of knowing what they put in it.” The section dedicated to cakes and snacks was very familiar to her: “I knew I wouldn’t buy any of them, but I would eye them and touch them every time.” She would only allow low-calorie portions she could control.
As we have seen, control is a major part of anorexia — Mathilde even talks about hypercontrol. “First it applies to food, but soon enough it covers your whole day: how long you’ll sleep, how many steps you’ll take, how much you’ll exercise, as well as very detailed study plans. Just like I counted calories, I calculated my time.”
Sociologist Claire Scodellaro explains: “With anorexia, behaviors seek to reach social excellence even beyond physical appearance. Especially girls and young women with anorexia, in school or higher education, are more prone to overachieving and striving for academic success.”
In Mathilde’s story so far, it is clear that she lacked self-confidence and took things very seriously. She displayed the main contributing factors to anorexia nervosa, as presented by Alain Perroud: in addition to a potential genetic predisposition, people with anorexia often suffer from anxiety and tend to be perfectionists. Anorexia reveals their need for control and enables them to take it to the extreme.
I ask Mathilde how she handled hunger and frustration. “In the first months, I was really hungry,” she admits. “But at some point, it’s almost as if the moment had passed. If you eat, you realize that you’re hungry, but when you are ill, you are so deep in hypercontrol, so scared to give in, that you just don’t. There was this voice in my head telling me that if I could hold on, it would be worth it. I would intellectualize my hunger, touching food, taking in the smells, but not eating it. The food might not go into your body, but would be present everywhere else, especially in your mind. I was constantly thinking about it. Every moment of my life was ruled by thoughts about food.”
Soon enough, Mathilde’s rapid weight loss caused concern among her relatives. She mentions her BMI. The body mass index is a tool that can be used to broadly categorize a person from underweight to obese, calculating their body fat percentage from their height and weight. After six months with anorexia, Mathilde’s BMI fell into the category of “extremely underweight” and malnutrition. Her obsessional cycle of restriction rapidly began to have a serious impact on her relationships with her friends and family. Today, she acknowledges their support, but also realizes how sad and helpless they felt. She had grown withdrawn, sullen and irritable, only caring about losing weight and performing her rituals. The euphoria of the first months was wearing off, replaced by constant angst and loneliness. Alain Perroud evokes a feeling of failure: “Suddenly, weight loss does not happen as easily; the praise you previously received turns into disapproval. You get consumed with the fear of regaining all the weight and canceling your efforts. Studies have shown that a severe or rapid weight loss, because of food deprivation, can cause irritability, anxiety, depressive tendencies, and decreased tolerance or interest in human relationships.” And as Claire Scodellaro explains, people suffering from anorexia nervosa can’t simply break free from the cycle: “Control gets out of control; which is precisely the reason why it is a pathology. Even when they are encouraged to eat more, they cannot simply let go of their rules.”
One day, Mathilde experiences another symptom of the illness: amenorrhea. She no longer has her period. She brings herself to go and see an endocrinologist, who is the first to utter out loud a diagnosis that her relatives foresaw: Mathilde has anorexia nervosa; she is at risk of dying and needs to receive medical treatment. On the doctor’s order, she drops out of school.
When I ask her about how her body reacted at the time, Mathilde explains that her body was left to choose between her organs, shutting down what was not immediately vital. Sitting down became painful; she would bump into things more often; her stomach was bloated because of all the water and soda she drank — which, along with poor digestion, caused persistent stomachaches. “And I was cold all the time,” she adds. “I was freezing inside, chilled to the bone.”
Ultimately, Mathilde no longer has a choice: she doesn’t believe that she is ill, but she follows the advice of her doctors and family, who fear for her life. Being extremely underweight, her body taps into her muscles, including her heart, which might stop at any moment.
Within two days, her family and her then-boyfriend had driven her to the hospital where she was admitted. She says she didn’t realize what was happening until the very last moment, when she saw her loved ones turn at the end of the corridor, wave at her and disappear. Left alone in her room, Mathilde cried for the first time, the realization finally hitting her — ”This is it,” she thought.
In Hell
“Everything that’s private is monitored: to pee, to eat, the interactions between patients; and you don’t have access to the Internet or your cellphone. The only things left were books and TV. There were bars on the windows, which we couldn’t even open.”
Read more
Mathilde was admitted to the hospital in May 2011, ten months after she became ill. I ask her which goals her hospitalization aimed to accomplish, which conditions would need to be met for her discharge.
“When you are admitted to the inpatient unit,” Mathilde recounts, “their first mission is to make sure you are medically cleared, which means you have to get physically healthy and regain weight — roughly two pounds a week. They also put you on medication: mood stabilizers, anxiolytics, antidepressants. You don’t even know exactly what you’re given. And you have to stay still; you have to spend a lot of your time immobile.” She mentions the contract established at the beginning: “Receiving visitors, the connection with my family, school work, the things that you enjoy, they call them ‘reinforcements’. When you fail to complete a goal, a reinforcement is withdrawn. If you don’t complete any goals during the week, you won’t get anything at all — no visitors, no phone, nothing.”
Treatment is composed of three different phases. The first step was to put on twenty pounds. For two weeks, she was not allowed to communicate with her family and felt extremely lonely. Her stay in the psychiatric ward of the hospital lasted four months — a time span that she experienced like a prison sentence, or a stay in hell.
“The hardest things there when you have anorexia, are to let go of your rules and rituals, to give up your control and relinquish it to the hospital staff; to go through long periods of solitude; and to eat again, to lose the sensation of emptiness and experience a harrowing fullness in your stomach.”
Alain Perroud tells me more about the challenges that come with regaining weight for patients with anorexia: “It is a very painful process: they are confronted with the fear of losing the control they sought and had, the fear of seeing their body change, of regaining their insecurities. During this arduous part of recovery, it is important that the health professionals take good care of the patients.”
Mathilde describes a typical day in the unit: “You wake up at 7 am and go take a shower. Then breakfast is served; more often than not you don’t get to choose where you sit. They check that you eat all the bread and finish the jam — because if you leave some, then it means that you are ‘not compliant’, which means that you won’t be entitled to the reinforcement that comes with eating everything on your plate. Then you go to your room to rest for an hour and a half — and when I say ‘rest’, I don’t mean doing whatever you like, I mean taking a seat or lying down and not being allowed to move an inch. Then you are supposed to ‘socialize’ with the other patients by doing collage or sudoku. Tea time is at 4 pm, followed by another hour of remaining perfectly still in your room — DVDs basically become your best ally. Dinner is served at 6:30; nurses patrol the room to make sure you don’t discuss topics that aren’t allowed. And finally you get up to take the pills that have been prescribed to you.” Mathilde laughs as she speaks about this, but as she acknowledges herself, it’s a nervous laughter.
For weeks she didn’t have access to a full length mirror. One day, the decision is made for her that she’s ready to see herself in a mirror — to see her body with the newly gained weight. “They just told me to follow them and led me to a mirror. And I broke down. Because when you put on two pounds a week, it is not distributed harmoniously. My legs were skinny and my upper body looked swollen.”
When she reached phase 2 of the treatment, Mathilde was allowed to take part in activities such as supervised cooking sessions. She also had the right to go out and see her visitors in other places than the common room — a walk in the park, going for a coffee… One of the tasks expected from them in that second phase was to be invited for a goûter and prepare one themselves. To make it to phase 3, when she is progressively allowed to spend some time back home, there was another challenge which makes Mathilde laugh: “You had to go to the restaurant with your nurse. They didn’t warn you in advance; they simply came to you like, ‘Girls, get ready, we’re going to the restaurant tonight’. It was such an absurd situation. The girls who come with you aren’t necessarily your friends, see? So you end up in a restaurant with a nurse and three other girls you’ve hardly spoken to before, sharing grim looks while the nurse is trying to put everyone at ease. She was nice that night, but still, we had to eat a whole pizza, a thing we hadn’t had for years and that was basically the devil incarnate.”
Throughout her hospitalization, Mathilde journaled, making collages and taking notes about her treatment and her illness. She kept the seven notebooks, and today she shows them to me. “I would always write the same things, because everyday always looked the same. When I tried to write, it took so much of my energy; and as I was interested in clothing and received a lot of magazines when I went inpatient, I would make collages of pretty girls or even random stuff. Sometimes I didn’t even know why I was doing it, I wasn’t looking at the pictures, I would just cut and paste them.” She reads an extract out loud — July 3rd, 2011, three weeks into her hospitalization: “I want to work in fashion. I don’t really know how to express my uneasy feelings, so the pictures do just that for me.” Another one: “Anger makes me so tired, sometimes resentment swallows me whole. I want to shout that I’m hurting, that I’m mad at everyone and I want it to show.” She comments on this: “I resented everyone: society, magazines, models, the nurse… even the tiny ant that would venture into my room. Inwardly I was fuming; it was like being a fireball inside. That’s why I needed to write. I just wanted to disappear and to be left alone.”
I notice passages written in capital letters, in red: “6 am I’m already awake, as if it was 11. Eyes wide open. Can’t manage to go back to sleep. That’s life. Shower in one hour. I don’t know why I stay here, to pee in jars and be stuffed. 93lb is fine with me.”
“I think the hardest thing for me is to handle my femininity, to be a woman. I want to be desired, but when I am, I feel somehow soiled.”
“Whether I’m ill or not, I won’t do it, they can go to hell with their 124lb, or else I’ll lose all the weight again when I’m discharged. My body isn’t me; it’s a stranger, an enemy, the thing that binds me to the earth and limits my dreams, my desire to be nothing but thin air. I don’t want to be on the earth but in the sky. I did one hundred and sixty sit-ups, as I felt too much guilt for what I ate. But hey, I think I got caught. Too bad for me. And here’s to hyperactivity.”
“Eating revives the anger within me — that freaking anger. But why? I’m stuffing my face and not moving, to not burn the calories. But what about in real life? Will we have rest times that last two hours, too? I mean… sometimes I feel like I’m going to lose my mind.”
I ask Mathilde about what she struggled with the most when she was in the psychiatric ward. She answers straight away: “Being treated like a child and being deprived of freedom. The realization that my free will, my freedom of movement, had been taken away from me. And the absence of privacy. The feeling of being dispossessed of my body and everyday actions.”
And indeed I am really shocked by this system of reward/punishment, of control over everything that’s private. I don’t understand the therapeutic benefits of such rules. I asked Alain Perroud about the value of this method. “I’ve been advocating against such practices for twenty-five years,” he admits. “They are traumatic and unhelpful, because they’re both harmful and inefficient. They should have disappeared from the health care providers’ practices a long time ago. Nowhere in the world has any study ever proved that it was useful; and yet that is most of the time how it works in France, in the units offering treatment for eating disorders.”
I also asked him about the relevance of a weight-based contract established between the doctors and the patient. Once again, Alain Perroud condemns a practice that he finds unhelpful and inhumane. “It became a habit to build this contract on how much weight the patient agrees to put on each week, with rewards if they succeed, punishments if they don’t. These goals are imposed by the medical staff; it all comes from the staff and is hardly ever discussed with the patient. The very notion of a contract is opposed to the foundation of a therapy, which is a cooperation: the patient is fighting against anorexia and the practitioner is fighting with them, on their side. The weight contract establishes a form of duality between ‘the good doctor’ and ‘the naughty patient’ who is either compliant or non-compliant with what they are asked to do.”
Mathilde went through the three phases and was finally discharged from the hospital. Soon enough, she noticed that instead of simply going back to her life as she expected, she was feeling deeply disconnected from the world. “I was tired all the time. I no longer knew how to be, how to behave normally.” It took a bit more than four months for her to be able to go back to her ‘normal life’. But the way she experienced her daily life was not ‘normal’: she found herself struggling, haunted by her time in hospital. “I wasn’t used to being around people anymore,” she says. “I didn’t know what to say to them. And I was constantly afraid of being punished. At home, if we didn’t eat at 12:00 sharp, by 12:15 I was in tears. I was scared that, if I didn’t follow the strict schedule I had been taught to follow in the hospital, I would have to go back there.”
“It’s almost as if, in the hospital, I was deprived of my free will, I had reverted to being a little girl. It makes me anxious. I am the opposite of what anorexia turned me into. I am swollen, depressed, scared of everything — scared of what I might say or do. I’m scared of the label they put on me: anorexia nervosa. I’m not so much scared of my illness so much as I am scared of the treatment, of feeling imprisoned.”
“I didn’t know what to say,” Mathilde goes on, “because I was just coming out of a very long day, a day that had lasted four and a half months. It had been so monotonous and still it was so difficult to talk about. I didn’t want to let the people I loved know how hard it had been for me.”
In her notebooks, there isn’t much content about the time that followed her release from the hospital. I know she attended a day hospital and briefly worked as a salesgirl in a clothing store. She was on antidepressants, anxiolytics and mood stabilizers, which made it hard for her to concentrate and to feel her emotions. She tells me, with a tad of guilt in her voice, that it didn’t last long until she decided to stop taking her meds. She felt gradually better and readjusted to her daily life; but it was only after eight months following her discharge that she was able to make plans for her future.
“I decided to resume my education and found a work study program in a field I really enjoyed — film and audiovisual. But within two weeks after getting back to school in September, I realized that it was impossible for me to stay focused in class for more than one hour. I really wanted it to work, I really tried to study, but it wouldn’t work. I went back to see the doctors and they told me it was the consequences of what the illness had done to my brain. We’ve talked a lot about my body, but the impact on the brain is equally important. The brain needs fat and sugar to work. Neural pathways that had been lost needed to be rewired. It would take time for me to recover my concentration and memory. And so I was really struggling mentally as well as academically, and slowly, without even realizing it or trying to control it, I began to lose weight again. And that’s when I realized it was really an illness.” Like many people suffering from anorexia, Mathilde experienced a relapse. “In November 2012, I got sick — caught a cold or something — which caused me to drop a few pounds in no time. I didn’t gain them back and my weight started to slowly decrease back to where I was the first time. I decided to call the hospital, even though I was still having nightmares about my time there and didn’t want to go back — because for the first time I acknowledged that I really needed help.”
For the second time, Mathilde is admitted to the inpatient hospital. She says this one was the worst, because she had been so sure she wouldn’t relapse, she wanted so badly not to disappoint anybody. The relapse added to the feeling of failure for having to drop out of school once again. At this point, Mathilde had no clue about what she was going to do with her life; she says, “I didn’t think it would take so much time to recover.”
A Long Day
“I was so disappointed in myself; I wanted so badly not to be among those who relapse. But I was also afraid that people would be disappointed in me.”
Read more
Mathilde was admitted a second time to the same hospital, this time for two weeks and with a little bit more freedom.
“I was allowed to have visitors, to keep my phone and my laptop. Because, this time, I told them I wasn’t in denial, I knew I needed help and I was the one reaching out to get it. I wanted us to find solutions together. They wanted me to go back to the psychiatric ward, but for me that was out of the question.”
Mathilde explains that she wanted to avoid the psychiatric ward at all costs; that what she wanted was to receive help in her own environment, at home. They told her that the recovery process would take much longer. “I said I’ll take the odds; I needed them to trust me and they did, and I think that was the right decision.” She left the hospital with a strict plan that included a minimum weight — were she to drop below that weight, she’d have to head back to the psych ward.
“This time, it was important for me to take an active part in my treatment, for myself, not merely to please others. I really wanted to understand; so I was willing to put in a lot of effort.”
For Alain Perroud, this new mindset in which Mathilde found herself after her relapse is essential to fully recover from anorexia: “Recovery won’t come from the doctors curing the patient; it is the patient who will heal themselves if they are conscious of being ill and that the illness puts their life at risk.”
“The second time I was discharged,” Mathilde explains, “it was my birthday. The first thing I asked was to go and eat cake, to mark the occasion. And unlike the first time, I didn’t think being discharged meant I was out of the woods. I thought, ‘Okay, now it begins.’ This new mindset was really helpful because I acknowledged that I was ill and that I couldn’t pretend nothing was wrong.”
Mathilde was ready to “fight the war”, even though she had no idea how long it would last. Sometimes it seemed to her that she would never get better. “I went through episodes of despair when I thought I would never be able to recover, to the point that I briefly considered accepting my life as it was.”
Although Mathilde chose to recover at home, her daily life was filled with appointments: she was monitored by her psychiatrist, her GP and a nutritionist. The frequency of the appointments was adjusted depending on how she was doing, whether she was making progress or suffering a relapse. But overall, it lasted five years. After trying psychoanalysis — which she found unhelpful and quit — Mathilde also reached out to a therapist who suggested systemic therapy. “That was life-saving for me. Rather than attempting to determine past causes, it focuses on the present and the situations you find yourself in, and aims to provide tools that will help you feel better in the moment before confronting the rest.”
I ask Mathilde about what happens in a session. “The therapist talks just as much as the patient, so it’s a real dialogue. Sometimes we would use drawings, exercises — visual things that are then discussed with the therapist who wants to make sure she understands what you bring to the session. What I liked was that it was so practical: I could talk about a concrete situation that upset me, and we would talk it through to find a solution together and to see how this could be applied to other situations. It’s like progressively building a shield.”
Alain Perroud outlines a few more features of systemic therapy: “The aim is to help the patient improve their relationship with others, by reflecting on the way they communicate and on their place in the family. This approach is especially relevant when the person suffering from anorexia is socially dependent on others — for example when they live at home with their family. The most interesting model for this therapy is perhaps what is called interpersonal therapy, which isn’t very common in France but is widely practiced in Anglo-American countries. The focus on relationships can tackle grief, changes in role, life transitions, feelings of loneliness… These issues can all be successfully addressed through this type of therapy for people with anorexia.”
Mathilde’s diary reads: “The work we do in therapy is beneficial but tiresome. It impacts my relationships with others; I need to destroy everything in order to rebuild everything.”
“Sometimes, I feel like I have found myself; but sometimes, I feel lost.”
“I cry, I feel lonely, misunderstood.”
“Sadness and melancholy always seem to be there; feelings that I had almost forgotten, that gave way to anger. I am angry, I feel like a victim struggling to find solutions, impatient. How are you supposed to be patient when you’re 23? How do you set your fervor aside for an illness that is eating you alive? How do you forgive, forgive yourself for your mistakes, for wasting those years of character building because of your brain that is ill?”
Interpersonal therapy. Relationships with others. I notice that Alain Perroud talks a lot about the role of the family in this type of therapy. I feel slightly surprised, for Mathilde hasn’t really talked about her family. I ask her about it and she tells me that she did have a few sessions with her parents. I notice that we hardly talked about how her parents might have played a part in the development of her illness. At this point, I have to admit that, when I was researching anorexia, it often came up that a toxic relationship with the mother could be a contributing factor. I wondered if there was a problem with her parents.
One day, as we are going through her notebooks, we find cards and letters sent by her family when she was in the hospital. I take the opportunity to ask her about it. She picks up a postcard from her father: “He just wrote this quote: ‘Children absorb the fear, the sorrow and the anxiety of adults.’” “Do you think your dad felt guilty, about your illness?” I ask her. “Well I think he reconsidered a lot of things about my childhood. But guilt and blame are pointless.” I ask her about her mother then. “I guess she felt bad about it,” Mathilde says, “just like every parent feels bad when something happens to their child — especially with mental illnesses. Because mental health isn’t as discussed as physical health; there is the belief that people suffering from a mental illness can control it. Sometimes you think that none of this would have happened if x thing hadn’t been done or said to trigger it — but it’s like History, we don’t actually know. It is a complex combination of personality, environmental factors and social relationships. It’s too easy to put the blame on parents when really it’s much more complex than that. But yes, I think they agonized over that, because of this bias that ties mental illness to ‘bad parents’. I find it really harsh, because there is no such a thing as ‘the perfect parent’, only people doing the best they can with what they have. My parents were very loving and overall really good parents that stuck by my side through everything.”
Apparently my assumptions were wrong. I questioned Alain Perroud about these preconceived notions regarding toxic family relationships and anorexia. “It has been hotly debated for the past forty years. In the 1970s, it was thought that the family was both the trigger of and the fuel for the illness. A systemic approach went as far as to consider the illness a mere symptom of a dysfunctioning family. To be clear, these notions were disqualified. Studies never proved that the hypotheses about overprotective mothers or absent fathers were relevant. The paradoxical conclusion of recent studies on the relationship between the family and anorexia nervosa, is that the more the family is proven to play a small-minimal role in the problem, the more the family is proven to play a big-major role in its resolution.”
About a year after her relapse, thanks to therapy and the support of her loved ones, Mathilde began to feel better. She got a job in a performing arts center — and that was where we met. Today she acknowledges how beneficial it has been for her, to find her place in a professional setting where she felt good. “It really helped me to socialize again and to be more than my illness. I made a lot of friends there and I can’t thank them enough. I don’t know if they realize how helpful and precious it has been, to be able to meet people, to chat with them, to just be with them and to see people laughing…”
In this new life, for the first time in ages, Mathilde not only feels better, she feels good. She also understands many things about the disorder. “The way I see it, I had been quiet for too long, I didn’t want to talk about it and kept pretending everything was fine, until my mind found another way to express my feelings. This is how I understand it. It had to be released, to be visible, and because I couldn’t find the words, it was translated through anorexia and weight loss.”
“When you were 20, at the time when you became ill,” I ask her, “what was your vision of a successful life?” She says she had no idea, or rather that her idea of a successful life didn’t fit what is usually expected of you when you are in your twenties. “I pictured having someone you love by your side, spending time with your loved ones, and having a job you’re interested in. But really, at the time, it wasn’t so much about work; it really was about the people dear to me, my friends and my family, and I thought it was a problem. I thought I lacked ambition and perhaps it meant that I wasn’t good enough. Even now my vision of a successful life is the same — but now I fully accept it. When I was 20, I didn’t accept it, because for one thing it wasn’t what would bring me money, it wasn’t enough with regard to society. I didn’t have the maturity yet to acknowledge that what mattered was whether or not it was enough for me. Now, the difference is that I know which life I want and move towards it. When something makes me happy, that’s what I go towards. And just this, for me is proof of being healed.”
“I’ve always been scared that fighting anorexia might become my whole identity. After the fight, what do I become? What purpose do I have? This war I’m fighting takes a lot of time and space, it is a part of who I am; I’m becoming an adult because of it.”
“I want to shout how happy I am to be alive, my joy when I feel it, my youth. Of course everything will come in due time. More than anything, I want to feel good and at peace.
“I don’t know if I can come back to that race. But do I really want to play by the rules? What if I don’t resume my education? What if I don’t succeed in achieving what I want? I don’t even want to think about it.”
“To find the right words to describe your feelings or emotions is still one of the hardest tasks I know of. If one day I manage to do it, I would have already won so much.”
After all this time, Mathilde can say it loud and clear: her difficult journey ultimately helped her to overcome her deepest fears and gave her the strength to live the life she wants to live. She talks about how, when you are 20, you regard failure as something inacceptable, something that is to be feared. “No one tells you that sometimes, failing at something becomes the ground you will be able to flourish on later. And this is something you tend to learn very late in life. Some of my friends who are between 26 and 35 are still really scared of failure, whereas I see failure as an opportunity to learn something and grow. Falling down doesn’t mean you will die from it. When you’re 20, you think that if you fall down, you will die. I was so afraid that I really did fall down, in the end, but at least now I’m no longer afraid.”
“Do you think recovery brought you the ability to appreciate the moment?” I ask Mathilde. “That’s what I’ve been doing these past four years,” she laughs. “It seemed like such a long day, suffering from anorexia, as if time had stopped, a day that never seemed to end. So now, I’m really more attuned to the present, to the immediacy of life. Everything I went through showed me I wasn’t invincible like I thought I was, and with that came the fear of not having lived the life I want to live. Those five years I spent consumed with anorexia, I will never get them back. And I don’t want to live like that anymore, I don’t want to wonder, ‘Will I be able to make up for this lost time?’ — I just want to live in the moment when it comes. I don’t want to have regrets.”
To a certain extent, Mathilde was lucky: her life was turned upside down for five years, but she managed to get back to a ‘normal life’ pretty quickly. Alain Perroud underlines how time consuming the illness is: “Suffering from anorexia nervosa can take up between three or five years of a person’s life, sometimes even a decade, and it takes a lot of time to recover from it. Their social life, relationships, and personal development will be put on hold during that time. This is why it is so hard in recovery to get back to those things, to find your place, find your purpose, to have a career and romantic relationships. Recovery is followed by a period of time when the individual is at risk of relapsing and needs to find a sense of stability.”
“When did you consider yourself healed?” is my next question to Mathilde. “When I started struggling with stuff that involved my emotions and that I did not restrict my food intake. Also, when I gained some weight back and didn’t cry. It annoyed me, but I didn’t cry and I didn’t act on it.
According to Alain Perroud, between 60% and 80% of people who suffered from anorexia are able to recover without lasting harm. I ask Mathilde about the traces of the illness that she still carries with her: “I’m still somewhere between passion/repulsion. I enjoy eating, but the less time I spend thinking about it and about what we’re going to eat, the better. I eat when I’m hungry. I still remember the calories, but it doesn’t affect me anymore. I no longer want to intellectualize food.”
“When I look at pictures of myself at 18 years old, I have the feeling that we have been several persons, taking turns living our life, one after the other. I can’t find a link between myself and this girl. She has curves, she’s laughing, she has her whole life ahead of her, and I’m pretty sure that, at 18, she believes in life. She has a lot of expectations about higher education, and about the world that is opening up to her. I’m afraid I have let her down. I can’t seem to establish a connection between each fragment of the girl I was.”
Today, Mathilde still has a distorted vision of her body, but she decided to not let body image be an issue. “Even if I don’t like the way I look, I go beyond that; I focus on the present moment and on taking part in life — because I have so much better to do! There’s more to life than being miserable about your appearance. To be honest, I prefer how I used to look, but I feel so much better now that it doesn’t matter anymore.”
Epilogue
“It feels like I’m living what I should have lived when I was 21, except that I can enjoy it a lot more now, because I am healed and independent. It’s almost better to be 21 when you are 31. I will never get back the time I should have spent carefree and that I didn’t get to experience because I was ill; but being 100% present and living in the moment allows me to make up for that time, somehow. And I enjoy it immensely.”
Read more
Although Mathilde won’t go as far as to say she is ‘glad’ she had anorexia, she is certainly glad that she recovered from it and learned a few things in the process. She explains that recovering from anorexia was a freeing experience that enabled her to break free from her inner demons and from the things she couldn’t handle before. “I learned that I want to be the kind of person who doesn’t judge others, who they are or how they react. I don’t think there is such a thing as a ‘normal person’ or a ‘normal behavior’. There is no ‘normal’ way to react when you are confronted with shock or illness.”
I ask my friend how she would describe herself today. “Today, I know what I no longer want, I’m starting to know what I do want, and to act accordingly — something that I wouldn’t do before. I allow myself to feel good, which is also new. I am rather happy, most of the time; I love partying; I love my friends, my family, and having a good time. I don’t like routines, and I enjoy facing a challenge, especially when it’s a bit absurd or crazy. I am more daring, I have more self-confidence. I’m doing the best I can and I don’t beat myself up as much as I used to when things don’t go as well as I would like. As for my physical appearance… well, I don’t think about it so much anymore.”
Since the last time I saw her, Mathilde cleared out her apartment and left, a bit impulsively, to see what it was like to live in Cambodia. We call each other often and she tells me all about her new adventures — the motorbike she intends to buy, the places she managed to visit in these pandemic times… She even tells me how her dislike for supermarkets is counterbalanced by the novelty of shopping in a foreign country where you get to see all sorts of things you have never seen before.
Before she left, Mathilde gave me her notebooks. I looked at the very last one. On the last page, she wrote:
“Today, I’m still learning; I am very wary, especially of myself. I’m trying to be someone I can rely on, and I know I still have to be patient, to not be too hard on myself when I fail, to process failure — this is what remains the hardest. I need to learn to take my time; to understand that things won’t change overnight — and accept it. These are the terms that will allow a bit of light to get in again. This note is a goodbye letter to Anorexia. It’s up to me now not to let her sit at my table. To tell her she doesn’t belong here, show her that I can exist without her. It’s time I begin to fight for myself — and for myself only.”
Help us tell the world’s stories
By supporting Frictions, you sustain a community of writers and journalists who explore the world through intimate stories.
Their work is funded by our studio and by the members of our Club. Join them with a one-time or monthly donation.
To read more of Mathilde’s diaries: Anorexia mon amour (French edition, available on Amazon).